top of page

Artificial Insemination vs. Open Mating: Navigating the Choices for VSH Honeybees

When it comes to breeding Varroa Sensitive Hygiene (VSH) honeybees, two primary approaches emerge artificial insemination (AI) and open mating. Both methods aim to increase VSH expression in bee colonies, but each comes with its own set of considerations. 

artificial insemination of a honey bee queen

Let's take a balanced look at both, acknowledging their benefits and limitations based on available information.

Artificial Insemination:

  • Benefits:

  • Precise control over mating, allowing for the selection of specific drone genotypes with high VSH expression.

  • Can be used to introduce new genetic material rapidly into a breeding program.

  • May be preferred for breeding isolated populations or specific genetic lines.

  • Limitations:

  • This can potentially lead to reduced genetic diversity, compromising colony resilience in the long run.

  • Requires specialized equipment and expertise, increasing overall breeding costs.

  • Drones raised for AI may not exhibit natural foraging and mating behaviors, potentially impacting colony performance.

Open Mating:

  • Benefits:

  • Promotes natural selection and genetic diversity, leading to potentially more resilient colonies.

  • Does not require specialized equipment or expertise, making it more accessible to beekeepers.

  • Allows drones to develop natural foraging and mating behaviors, potentially benefiting colony fitness.

  • Limitations:

  • Less control over mating, making it more difficult to guarantee specific drone genotypes.

  • The introduction of undesirable drone genotypes from neighboring apiaries is possible.

  • Requires careful selection of drone sources and management of surrounding apiaries for optimal results.

Making the Choice:

The choice between AI and open mating for VSH breeding depends on individual beekeeping goals, resources, and preferences. While AI offers precise control and rapid genetic introduction, open mating promotes natural selection and genetic diversity, potentially leading to more resilient colonies in the long run.

Key Considerations:

  • The scale of operation: Larger apiaries with dedicated breeding programs may find AI more efficient.

  • Local beekeeping environment: Open mating requires careful management of surrounding apiaries for optimal VSH selection.

  • Long-term sustainability: Open mating may contribute to greater long-term colony resilience through increased genetic diversity.

  • Personal preference: Beekeepers should choose the method that aligns best with their values and management practices.


Both AI and open mating have their place in VSH breeding programs. Careful consideration of individual needs and available information is crucial for making the best choice for your beekeeping journey.

10 views0 comments


bottom of page